John Turturro explained why he declined to return to The Penguin, citing his completed journey with Carmine Falcone. It wasn’t just scheduling—his decision goes deeper. Read on to discover the real reason!
Turturro cited discomfort with the show’s heavy emphasis on violence, particularly violence toward women, stating, “That’s not my thing.” This decision highlights his commitment to values over convenience. As a fan of Gotham’s rich storytelling, I admire actors who prioritize social responsibility, enriching the narratives we love. Explore more on how Turturro’s stand reshapes perspectives in the DC Universe.

John Turturro recently explained why he declined to reprise his role as Carmine Falcone in The Penguin. While scheduling conflicts were rumored, his main reason was the show’s violence, particularly toward women, and he felt his character’s story was complete.
In Turturro’s absence, Mark Strong stepped in to play Falcone in flashbacks exploring Sofia’s past. As someone who dives deep into character arcs and media representation, I find Turturro’s values-driven choice inspiring. It’s a call for better storytelling in the DC Universe, urging creators to prioritize thoughtful narratives. Discover how this decision reshapes expectations in superhero adaptations.
In a Variety interview, John Turturro revealed he declined returning as Carmine Falcone in The Penguin due to the show’s violence, particularly against women, and his commitment to meaningful storytelling.
What John Turturro’s Comments Mean

The fourth episode of The Penguin, “Cent’anni,” centers on Sofia and explores the show’s violent themes. Framed by her father, Carmine Falcone, for his murders of women in Gotham, Sofia endures harrowing events that create a powerful yet unsettling narrative.
Given the violent nature of Carmine Falcone’s role, it’s understandable why John Turturro opted not to return. While scheduling conflicts were cited initially, the show’s focus on such disturbing themes likely influenced his decision. As someone who examines character dynamics, I admire Turturro’s stand for values-driven storytelling. His decision challenges media creators to prioritize responsible narratives, aligning with audiences seeking meaningful representation.
Our Take On John Turturro’s Comments

John Turturro declined to return as Carmine Falcone in The Penguin, citing scheduling conflicts and discomfort with the show’s portrayal of violence against women. He explained that his packed schedule forces him to choose roles carefully, aligning with his values. While his absence is notable, Mark Strong delivers a strong performance as Falcone, ensuring the character’s continuity in the series.